How to Leverage Testimonials for Warmer Prospecting Calls

When it comes to prospecting, few things build trust faster than the words of a satisfied client. Testimonials are a powerful yet often underutilized tool that can help turn cold calls into warm conversations—and warm conversations into real opportunities.

Here’s how to effectively leverage testimonials in your prospecting strategy:

1. Choose the Right Testimonial

Not all testimonials are created equal. When making prospecting calls, select a testimonial that’s:

• Relevant to the type of client you’re calling
• Specific about the results they got working with you
• Authentic and emotionally resonant

Example:
“We were nervous first-time homebuyers, but Sarah made the whole process easy and stress-free. We closed on time and even under budget!”

That speaks louder than anything you could say about yourself.

2. Lead With Social Proof

Instead of diving straight into your pitch, begin the conversation with a brief story:

“I recently helped a couple in your neighborhood sell their home above asking price in just six days. They were thrilled with how smooth the process went…”

People are more likely to listen when they hear about someone like them who had a positive experience.

3. Use Testimonials to Address Objections

Most prospects have similar concerns: trust, time, cost, or complexity. Match a testimonial to each common objection so you can gently neutralize doubt:

• Concerned about time? Share a testimonial that highlights efficiency.
• Worried about cost? Share how you helped someone save money or maximize their budget.

4. Include Testimonials in Your Follow-Up

If your prospect doesn’t answer or asks for more info, send a follow-up email that includes a well-written testimonial or even a short video clip from a happy client. A real voice adds credibility and warmth.

5. Keep Your Testimonial Library Fresh

Keep collecting feedback from happy clients, and organize them by category (buyers, sellers, investors, relocators). The more specific and relatable the testimonial, the more persuasive it becomes.

Testimonials work because they prove you’re not just talking a good game—you’re delivering real results. Use that social proof to build credibility, open doors, and deepen trust from the first call.

Looking to be part of our Real Estate Expansion Team or referral network? Fill in the form below, and let’s start a conversation about how we can collaborate. Your referrals are important to us, and we value the potential of growing our network with like-minded professionals. We’re excited to connect with you!